We've had this debate a thousand times, coming to a universal hivemind consensus that at the current time, WRPGs are leagues ahead of JRPGs.
The Wticher 2, Dark Souls, Mass Effect 3, Skyrim, Dragon Age II, Deus Ex 3 all agree
They are that is true. But they are NOT on art style. Only on gameplay (and maybe story but I still prefer linear JRPGs for a pure story experience.)
Anyways I won't touch WRPGs until they do something about their atrocious art
Shame too, I really really want to play one they really do seem right up my alley.