I got all the way past that last year's E3 demo. This game is great, and I love it, but it does NOT deserve over 50 god damn perfect scores so far. I would have given it a 9.5 at best. I hate when games that really push hiding and running away, suddenly make you kill everything, like when you fight your first bloater. Its damn ridiculous, and was one of people's common faults with Deus Ex:Human Revolution, but since this is Naughty Dog, they get a pass? Oh, not to mention the many glitches I ran into, like the second cutscene taking 5 minutes to load, the ground disappearing beneath me, and the voices not appearing in said cutscene that took 5 minutes to load. It also happened in a few other places too.
Combat is fun though. I also love how much of a dirty mouth Ellie has. Troy Baker is unrecognizable as Joel, except when he breaks his southern accent. Great game so far.