When I read the thread title I thought the same as most people here: Valkyria Chronicles
Oddly, I didn't care too much.
I was kinda perturbed by the setting to begin with though, the anime influence that trickled it's way to the game annoyed me as well. Battles were pretty great, though, I do confess. Unfortunately I didn't beat it when I saw it's trade-in value was high. D:
Glad to see I'm not the only one who didn't care it....
VC actually fell off the backlog list for me awhile ago and into the realm of "I Don't Care to Finish"..... Its not a bad game... its just not my taste... despite the heavy anime influence, which I do love, everything else about it proved sort of lackluster for me.....
My pics for top PS3 RPGs are definately Disgaea 4 (even though its a SRPG), Disgaea 3 (though I liked 4 a heck of alot more), Tales of Graces F (and yes, I say that with confidence after one day with it) and Hyperdimension MK2.... but in all fairness, I have yet to give Resonance of Fate, Ar Tonelico, or Zill Ol' a try, which are all on my "to play" list....
So in short, yea I agree with pretty much everything everyone has said, minus the VC favoritism.