25 Reasons The Evil Within will Rock
Even with all this points (which I knew about), there's still a lot faith put into TEW that fans of the genre have done like myself that have followed the project closely, as well as the more jaded/cynic fans that changed their minds after playing a demo at a event. Why? Because this kind of game doesn't really exists outside Resident Evil and Fatal Frame nowadays.
Who knows what happened with the Siren series after Siren: Blood Curse, which was pretty cool at the time and was a successful project for what I know.
Either way, TEW is mainly exciting for the kind of environment the game is coming from. There's lots of people from Clover Studio, Old-school Capcom, Platinum Games, Grasshopper Manufacture and Game Republic that have done great work in multiple games in the past that are related to TEW's development in some way, and mixing that with the new blood they have at Tango Gameworks I'm certain something great can come out of it.