Am I allowed to pick The Last of Us? It's not technically out until after E3, right? ;)
Seriously, though, the big news from this E3 was obviously the new consoles, but I wasn't super-impressed by any of the games. I guess the one that stands out most for me was FFXV, but I think that's just because I was so shocked to see the game actually running after all these years. Still have no idea how it will really play.