Let's take a quote from your link
The question that has been going around is not particularly artfully worded, and I think that has caused some of the disagreements
Which is exactly the issue. Don't you ever remember those trick questions in math class that are worded in a fashion that they literally are unable to be answered? The question in the original link suffers this same problem.
Yet I seem to be your "internet target" here. Normally if you had simply posted a link then your point would have artfully been made. But since I am obviously your sole target in this I find it very hard to take what you say seriously.
Looks like somebody's mad.