I... dunno if I jive with that. I seek out good games, and I don't care if it's a AAA title or a weird-ass Japan-only RPG or an indie title that got some positive attention over Twitter. When anyone disdains a certain development class (?) of game for being indie or AAA I think it's just denying one some good experiences.
What I meant was I fear being spoiled by the production value and inherent "bells and whistles" of AAA titles and newer games. I don't hold bias toward production class at all, but I certainly find going back to (or starting) certain titles after others can prove jarring depending on the circumstances. This tends to prove true for me, more often then not, within the ps2/ps3 era. In other words, if I go back and play an SNES game I rarely feel it is difficult to appreciate.
CASE AND POINT: I had a real love affair with NISA releases for quite awhile. Compile Hearts and Idea factory were not names that scared me one bit. Played hyperdimension and loved it, played agarest war 2 and loved a lot about it but put it down. Then I played Alice Madness Returns, a wee bit of Mortal Kombat, Tales of Graces F and finally X-Com. When I tried to get back to Agarest 2 I simply could not appreciate it like I did at first. Never finished it (sadly), nor did I find the thought of getting to Hyperdimension V all that appealing.
CASE AND POINT 2: Suikoden 2 is a magnificent title by my standards. However, last year when I played it post The Wind Waker HD I found it tough to to enjoy initially for all the wrong reasons.
In short, what I should have said (in the first place) was that I love that the age of or the production value of a title does not generally impact my criticisms of what I am playing. My fear however is that with enough time spent playing higher budget titles, I will become one of "those guys" who's sensibility and taste really is impacted more than I care for it to be by issues like "frame rate" and whatnot. Hence the "shame" enters the picture.
^^^^This does in fact severely cripple (or at the very least, compromises) my ability to have a good experience with some games. You are entirely correct good sir.
Of course this is all very silly and superficial, as I know a quick play-through of Secret of Mana for the 101st time cleanses my palette and sensibility nicely :)