360 is perfect as long as you don't need the D-Pad. If you do it becomes godawful. I don't know how much better xbones is. I know they wanted to put in a less shitty pad, but half the problem feels like the positioning. So gotta give it to the dual shock for overall usability.
Although for dpad/analogue positioning I will give special mention to the N64 controller. While not a great controller having seperate handles for for the dpad and analogue was kind of genius. It was just wasted since N64 didn't really have 2d games or rpgs to make use of it so nobody noticed.