Am I the only one who would be happy with either SMT OR a persona game?
Devil Survivor (even though it's a total offshoot) got me interested in the more SMT side of the series (Where you can either be lawful, neutral, or an outright chaotic bastard), so now I want to play nocturne.
However, I enjoyed the snot out of Persona 3 and 4, so I wouldn't mind a sequel, so long as there's some upgrades to the battle system. Not that the battle system is bad, but there was little improvement between 3 and 4's (With the exception of controlling all characters, WHICH WAS AWESOME).
Oh, and Chie's GALACTIC PUNT.
Sort of on topic, but I just want to say that Gin's Route in Devil Survivor has made me want to throw my DS through a window. BOSS GAUNTLET A GO-GO.