Well it's not going to going to get the same score because games are rated relative to what makes games "fun" in this era. Like it or lump it, repetitive battles and random encounters don't add up. Certain things don't age well, etc.
As for CT and FT:WotL: Those are bad examples.
Chrono is beloved partly because of it's charming style and spritework.
And Tactics is a prime example of an excellent turn based srpg
It's just the reviewers POV that P2 is just dated, so what?