They did smell like smoke, but I was aware of this, thanks to the previous transaction where someone was disgruntled by it, and made the purchase knowing this. I also firmly believe it is an easy mistake, if someone has not been in the business of selling items very often. I only started putting smoke free household in my auctions on ebay because I was told by a friend that it is a reassuring thing for some people, and gives them more confidence in bidding, otherwise I would not have known. He was wise enough to put something down after someone complained, so at the very least I give him credit for that. I also can see how the air freshener could be funny, but also how it could be something of a "well f you" sort of response as well. It was an unfortunate misunderstanding, he learned from it, I say leave it at that..but then again thats just me..also...nice try hiding the snickers...YOU CANT HIDE CANDY FROM THE FAT GUY! NOM NOM NOM.