I don't think what i said was too much at all. When i posted that this thread said deciding the "best rpg" lists like that only bring out morons and fanboys who fight over what they think is "best" when it's really only a matter of taste. Some people will tell you Big Rigs is the best game ever, doesn't mean we're all supposed to agree with it.
I admit the original title was not appropriate, that's why i changed it. Of course each player has their own favorite games. However, I think a ranking like this one might be of some use : 1) It provides an exhaustive list of existing RPGs 2) It can give an idea of the quality of the games (with the limitations that are discussed here, when I look at the list, I don't see any dumb game in the top 100)
bullshit and bad for you.
It is still a bit too much in my opinion as i hardly understand how the existence of this list is gonna be bad for me in any possible way^^. At worst, it is useless.
T blocks rock.
I totally agree, T blocks saved my life so many times...
I don't think I should be allowed to vote in this at all. I think The World Ends With You is the best RPG out there. Oh god, it feels so wrong to say that.
Why not ? Tastes are tastes. Besides, even if not the best for me, this one was quite refreshing.
I'm not discounting it's greatness, but for the love of all that's kinky and filthy why is SotN on this list? It along with all the Zelda titles is not an RPG.
My definition of an RPG is, I admit, a VERY large one and includes the action/aventure and turn based startegy games with some RPG elements.