The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time - Worst RPG Of All Time?

From what I have read in magazines, gathered from Miyamoto's statements, and assumed from past games in the series, The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time is going to fall short of ANY RPG, including Beyond the Beyond.

Why? Simple. The STORY LINE.

Ultra Game Players November 1997 reported that it was the same old save the princess and get the Triforce story. This may have been OK back in 1991, but it is not OK in 1998. ANY RPG today has an infinately better story than The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past, and most probably better than The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time. Think about it: Final Fantasy VII is a story about the sanctity of life, and how it is everlasting, as well as countless other themes. Final Fantasy Tactics dwelves into human nature, criticism of the medieval Catholic Church, and countless other themes. Wild ARMs is a story about discovering that lost light of virtue within humanity, and it shows us that the real enemy was not the Metal Demons, but the loss of virtues within humans. Suikoden is an epic story of Chinese legend. Vandal Hearts takes a look at the ethics of war, and betrayal. Alundra goes deep into a people's faith, and how they deal with the realization that THEIR god is actually evil. Breath of Fire III.... well, it may not have the best plot or deepest themes in my opinion, but it still outshines a save the princess story. Kartia: The Word of Fate is a game that has 2 beautiful stories, but whose real strength lies in its character interactions and development. Parasite Eve should be "required gaming" for biology class, and it also has an exciting story. And someone on the Working Designs message board stated that "Xenogears makes The Iliad look like Dr. Suese."

And then there is The Legend of Zelda series, with its save the princess and get the triforce story.

Why are we holding this game to lower standards than other RPGs? Many people would say, "Oh, but it isn't an RPG!" Yes it is. It is an ACTION/RPG. Now, I ask you, why do we not hold it to the standards that we hold other action/RPGs to, such as Alundra?

I would take Alundra over The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time anyday. The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time is a game that will sell in droves, and has sold in droves, but it pales in comparison to other RPGs, even an RPG like Beyond the Beyond.

If you wish to submit an editorial of your own, or make a counterpoint of an editorial, please review the submissions page for guidelines.