iTunes - Podcast RSS Feed - Podcast RSS Feed - News RPGFan YouTube Channel RPGFan on Facebook RPGFan on Twitter


RPGFan Social Links

Three Industry Giants - Counterpoint

I liked Abe's editorial on three massive, excellent RPG's. I liked it until I read his section on "storyline".

I can understand that people like different things. I, personally, feel that Final Fantasy VII was the greatest game ever made, but I won't get into that now. You can e-mail me and bash away. =)

Even with my love of Final Fantasy VII, I'll be the first to admit that there are games out there with better plots. Xenogears. How Abe put Lunar:SSSC, which has the SIMPLEST plot of the three, above Xenogears, is beyond me. No matter how much he liked or disliked it, there is no denying it had a deeper and better plot than the other two. Xenogears's plot is like a rope. There's a main theme, main story, and there are lots of little strands that make up that story. The war between Kislev and Aveh, or Solaris' watching over the land. Shevat's hiding in the sky, or Ramsus's plans on killing 'him'. Or maybe Miang, and her plans...or Grahf...what does he want? What is wrong with Fei? Who is 'Id'? What is Citan doing..?

The plot is deeply woven and intricate. Lunar's, on the other hand, is simplistic. Alex must save Luna, stop the bad guy. It never elevates beyond that, but through lively characters and good execution, it does well. But even the characters in Lunar don't hold a candle to Xenogears' cast. The characters in Lunar aren't deep, there's no denying it- they're shallow but entertaining. In Xenogears, each character is distinct, different, and has an interesting past or personality uncovering the obstacles as the game progresses, makes them all the more alive.

I also don't understand why Abe disliked the translation, it was fine. There was a lot of text in Xenogears, and it seemed to me like Abe wasn't attentive enough to stay and read. Sure, Disc 2 is almost ALL reading, but it's an amazing plot revelation. What would you rather have, "battles", or the climax of an amazingly woven plotline?

If you wish to submit an editorial of your own, or make a counterpoint of an editorial, please review the submissions page for guidelines.

Back




Featured Content
Project Destati: LIGHT Review
Project Destati: LIGHT
Music Review
Shadows: Heretic Kingdoms Review
Shadows: Heretic Kingdoms
Review
Rhythm Encounter 19 - String Quartet
Rhythm Encounter 19
feat. Taylor Davis
Game of Thrones - A Telltale Games Series Review
Game of Thrones: Episode 1
Review
Random Encounter Episode 88
Random Encounter Episode 88
Podcast
Kingdom Hearts II.5 HD ReMix Review
Kingdom Hearts II.5 HD ReMix
Review
Pier Solar and the Great Architects HD Review
Pier Solar and the Great Architects HD
Review