Games of the Year

RPGFan Games of the Year 2024: Best Story

Metaphor ReFantazio - Best Story of 2024

Winner: Metaphor: ReFantazio

Writeup by Sean Cabot

There are a few JRPGs from the past few years whose handling of prejudice and slavery never sat well with me. Cliche and underdeveloped core themes overshadow any insightful points. Metaphor: ReFantazio touches upon common elements related to these topics, but only as much as it needs to. The result is a game whose portrayal of the sheer dehumanizing horror of a racially stratified society actually carries meaningful dramatic weight. 

To get more specific, Metaphor addresses direct prejudice, the struggles that biracial individuals are met with from all sides, and how a prejudiced environment encourages even the non-prejudiced to discriminate. It is also very clear on the point that legal equality alone cannot hope to solve the problems caused by generations of institutionalized racial discrimination, especially in a society espousing competition and meritocracy as moral virtues. Many games would buckle under such thematic weight, but Metaphor does it with ease. Even without its infectiously likable cast, whose diverse backgrounds offer great arcs and exemplary worldbuilding, it would still be a contender for the year’s best story. With them? It’s hard for anything else to measure up. 


Runner-Up: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth

Writeup by Tim Rattray

Zack aside, my sky-high hopes for Final Fantasy VII Rebirth’s story after the endless speculation following Remake’s ending were met and then some.

This remix of the original game’s journey is custom-made to keep veteran players on their toes and utterly thrilled while still hitting all those classic beats. The cast is also better characterized than ever, thanks to both great localization and voice acting. I don’t think there’s a single character I don’t love, even Cait Sith. And that ending… what an emotional rollercoaster both upon first experiencing it and with all the fan theorizing that ensued after, me included. I can’t wait to see how the team (hopefully) sticks the landing in part three.


Readers’ Choice: Best Story of 2024

Winner: Metaphor: ReFantazio (41.1% of votes)

Runner-Up: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth (24.9% of votes)

Sean Cabot

Sean Cabot

Sean is a reviewer for RPGFan. Not content to merely indulge in a genre known for obscene length, he decided to indulge in similarly long-winded subjects like tokusatsu and comics. Being stuck between all of these interests has left him with a truly terrifying backlog, but he still swears that someday he will finish 15% of it. For him, genre is no object, and it is absolutely vital to experience something new every day.